If you were edgar ,would you take gloucester to a high hill? Why؟
إجابة الطالب المختصرة من خلال موقع بوابة الإجابات هي
Yes, if I were Edgar, I would take Gloucester to a high hill to help him escape from danger and to protect him. Gloucester was blind, and Edgar wanted to prevent him from being harmed by his enemies. Taking him to a high hill could also symbolize offering him safety and a better perspective on life.
If I were Edgar in Shakespeare's *King Lear*, I absolutely would take Gloucester to a high hill, even though it's a complete fabrication. Here's why:
* **Restoring Hope and Will to Live:** Gloucester is utterly despondent and suicidal. He believes his suffering is unbearable and wants to end his life by leaping off a cliff. My primary goal as Edgar is to prevent this. Taking him to a "high hill" and then "miraculously" surviving a fall from it is a theatrical trick designed to give Gloucester a renewed sense of hope. It convinces him that there is a higher power, divine intervention, or some force that has saved him. This, in turn, can reignite his will to live.
* **Teaching Gloucester a Lesson About Despair:** Gloucester's despair has blinded him to the truth and made him susceptible to the manipulations of Edmund. The staged "fall" is a way to shock him out of his self-pity and despair and encourage him to re-evaluate his worldview. By surviving, he might realize that things aren't as hopeless as they seem and that he can endure hardship.
* **Protecting Him From Real Suicide:** Most simply, by preventing Gloucester from actually jumping off a cliff, I'm saving his life. Even if the means are deceptive, the end justifies them in this desperate situation. I know that Gloucester, in his current state of mind, is a danger to himself.
* **Maintaining My Disguise and Gaining Trust:** I am still disguised as Poor Tom at this time. By playing along with Gloucester's desire for suicide and leading him to this "cliff," I maintain my disguise and gain his trust. This allows me to continue guiding and protecting him. If I suddenly revealed my true identity, Gloucester might not believe me or accept my help.
* **Acting as a "Good Angel":** I believe that guiding my father towards a better emotional state is my duty as his son. I am playing the role of a "good angel," using whatever means necessary, even deception, to help him overcome his darkness.
* **Opportunity for Self-Reflection:** By staging the fall, I also create an opportunity for Gloucester to reflect on his past mistakes and seek redemption. The experience of "death" and "rebirth" can be a catalyst for personal growth.
In summary, taking Gloucester to a "high hill" is a calculated risk, but it is a necessary act of compassion and protection. It is a way to restore his hope, teach him a lesson, and ultimately, save his life.
اذا كان لديك إجابة افضل او هناك خطأ في الإجابة علي سؤال If you were edgar ,would you take gloucester to a high hill? Why اترك تعليق فورآ.
